I know I'd go for wishlist games. I hate deciding what someone else might like. You guys should check out the queue and add more games to your wishlist. You can customize it or leave it wide open like I do-
I've added like fifty games to my wishlist since it came out. I also notice the store shows me a lot less games I'd hate and more obscure ones pop up.
Go to the store and scroll down to where it says to view your queue, go to the upper left and click on store-explore or click "view my queue" when on any game page.